Pizza preferences can tell you a lot about a culture, and Canadian pizza tastes are as diverse and interesting as the country itself. At Pizza73, we've served millions of pizzas across Canada, giving us unique insights into what toppings Canadians truly love. Here's our definitive ranking of the top 10 pizza toppings that Canadians can't get enough of.
1. Pepperoni
No surprises here! Pepperoni remains the undisputed champion of pizza toppings in Canada, accounting for over 30% of all pizzas ordered. Canadians love the spicy, slightly smoky flavor and the way those little circles of deliciousness curl up and crisp at the edges.
Interesting fact: Canadian pepperoni tends to be slightly spicier than its American counterpart, a nod to the multicultural influence on our food preferences.
2. Mushrooms
Coming in at a strong second place are mushrooms. Versatile, flavorful, and beloved by vegetarians and meat-eaters alike, mushrooms add an earthy umami flavor that complements the cheese and sauce perfectly.
Regional trend: British Columbia residents order mushroom pizzas at a higher rate than any other province, possibly due to the region's greater focus on plant-based diets.
3. Bacon
Canada is famous for its bacon, so it's no surprise that we love it on our pizzas too! The salty, smoky flavor pairs wonderfully with the sweetness of tomato sauce. Whether it's traditional strip bacon or Canadian bacon (back bacon), this topping is a national favorite.
Popular combination: The "Canadian Classic" featuring bacon and mushrooms is our third most ordered specialty pizza.
4. Extra Cheese
Is extra cheese technically a topping? Canadians certainly think so! Whether it's a blend of mozzarella and cheddar or our special three-cheese mix, Canadians love their pizzas extra cheesy.
Fun fact: Quebec residents order extra cheese more frequently than any other province, often requesting local cheese varieties as well.
5. Green Peppers
Adding a fresh, slightly sweet crunch to pizzas, green peppers are the most popular vegetable topping after mushrooms. They add color, texture, and a burst of freshness that balances the richness of cheese and meat toppings.
Health bonus: Green peppers are rich in vitamin C and add nutritional value without adding many calories.
6. Grilled Chicken
A relatively recent addition to the pizza topping hall of fame, grilled chicken has rapidly become one of Canada's favorites. It's a leaner protein option that pairs well with a variety of other toppings.
Rising trend: Orders for specialty pizzas featuring grilled chicken have increased by 45% over the past five years, particularly among the 25-34 age demographic.
7. Ham and Pineapple
Yes, the controversial Hawaiian pizza actually originated in Canada! Created in 1962 by Sam Panopoulos in Ontario, this sweet and savory combination continues to divide pizza lovers. Despite the debates, it remains the 7th most popular topping combination in the country.
Debate settled: Our ordering data shows that 52% of Canadians approve of pineapple on pizza, while 48% prefer to keep their pizza pineapple-free.
8. Hot Peppers
Canadians aren't afraid of a little heat! Banana peppers, jalapeños, and other hot peppers add a spicy kick that many pizza lovers crave. The contrast between the spicy peppers and the cooling cheese creates a perfect balance of flavors.
Regional preference: Prairie provinces order hot peppers at nearly twice the rate of the national average. Maybe it's those cold winters!
9. Italian Sausage
Seasoned with fennel and other herbs, Italian sausage brings a complex flavor profile to any pizza. Its slightly sweet, slightly spicy taste makes it a sophisticated alternative to pepperoni.
Pairing recommendation: Italian sausage pairs exceptionally well with roasted red peppers and onions – a combination that's especially popular in Ontario.
10. Onions
Rounding out our top 10 are onions, which add a sweet, aromatic flavor when cooked and a sharp bite when added fresh. They complement almost any other topping and add depth to the overall flavor profile of the pizza.
Chef's tip: Try caramelized onions on your next pizza for a gourmet twist on this classic topping.
Regional Specialties
Beyond the national favorites, Canada's diverse regions have developed their own unique pizza preferences:
Atlantic Canada
Seafood toppings like smoked salmon and lobster are more common here than anywhere else in the country. Donair pizza, featuring spiced ground beef and a sweet garlic sauce, is a Halifax specialty that's gaining popularity throughout the region.
Quebec
Quebec's French influence shows in their preference for gourmet toppings like prosciutto, arugula, and fig. Montreal-style pizza often features a thinner crust and more adventurous topping combinations.
Ontario
The multicultural hub of Toronto has introduced a world of pizza fusion, with toppings reflecting the city's diverse population. Butter chicken pizza, kimchi pizza, and jerk chicken pizza can all be found in this culinary melting pot.
The Prairies
Prairie provinces show a preference for hearty, meat-heavy pizzas, with combinations like the "Meat Lover's Special" ordering at 40% above the national average.
British Columbia
BC's health-conscious population has embraced plant-based pizza toppings, with vegan cheese alternatives and vegetable-forward combinations particularly popular in Vancouver and Victoria.
Emerging Trends
While the classics remain popular, we're seeing exciting new trends in Canadian pizza preferences:
- Plant-based proteins: Vegan pepperoni, plant-based chicken, and other meat alternatives are growing in popularity.
- Artisanal toppings: Ingredients like truffle oil, burrata cheese, and fig jam are appearing on more gourmet pizza options.
- Global flavors: Toppings inspired by global cuisines, such as tandoori chicken, bulgogi beef, and shawarma, reflect Canada's multicultural identity.
- Local sourcing: Locally produced cheeses, meats, and vegetables are increasingly important to Canadian pizza consumers.
Conclusion
Whether you're a pepperoni purist or an adventurous eater willing to try pineapple and hot peppers together, Canada's diverse pizza preferences have something for everyone. At Pizza73, we celebrate this diversity by offering a wide range of toppings to satisfy every pizza craving.
Next time you're ordering pizza online from Pizza73, why not try something new? Or stick with the classics – after all, they became favorites for a reason!
What's your favorite pizza topping combination? Let us know in the comments, or better yet, order your perfect pizza and share a photo with us on social media using #Pizza73Favorites.
